← All sports watches: price and scores

Garmin Forerunner 165 vs Polar Street X

Which one to pick? Scores by criterion, checked new prices and the Picksly verdict.

Garmin Forerunner 165 scores higher (38/100 vs 33). New price not checked for at least one of them.

Garmin Forerunner 165 · $192 at AmazonView offer

Picksly may earn an affiliate commission on these links, at no extra cost to you. Only offers whose link may earn Picksly a commission are shown. How Picksly is funded

Which to pick by profile and use

By profile

  • Budget: not scored for both.
  • Smart: not scored for both.
  • Premium: Polar Street X (36), the only one of the two scored.

Scores out of 100. A gap under 3 points counts as a tie.

Picksly scores

CriterionGarmin Forerunner 165Polar Street X
Overall score38/10033/100
Battery≈ 21/100≈ 14/100
Features31/10031/100
Weight90/10083/100
New price checked$192
at Amazon · Price checked on 11/15/2026
View offer
not measured

Picksly may earn an affiliate commission on these links, at no extra cost to you. Only offers whose link may earn Picksly a commission are shown. How Picksly is funded

How these scores are calculated

Garmin Forerunner 165 sheet → Polar Street X sheet →